borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 14

Prior to my rewatch, the main thing I remembered about season 14 was the Ma’lak box. Turns out there wasn’t a lot more to remember…
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 13

When I finished rewatching season 12 I wasn’t sure if I’d find season 13 better or worse…
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 12

I’m back to my Supernatural season reviews after 3 months off to move from Chicago to North Carolina and celebrate the holidays in my new home! And my New Year’s resolution is to finish my SPN rewatch before my daughter has her baby next month! So on to season 12…
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 11

My memory of season 11 was that it was pretty good, definitely better than 7 to 10, and my rewatch confirmed this impression. There was a run of really interesting cases in the middle of the season, and the arc with Dean and Amara was intriguing, showing us a vulnerability in Dean that we hadn’t seen before. I also think it made a difference that the boys were finally working together and (mostly) communicating.

Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 10

This is the season that has my all-time favorite episode of the entire series…
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 9

I must have used up all my agravation on season 8 because I didn’t find myself having a very intense reaction to season 9. It was kind of, well, you have to accept the mess of season 8 as canon, so all there is to do is see how they play it out in season 9…
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 8

So I went into season 8 with the foreknowledge that this is the season where Sam starts out very out-of-character by having not looked for Dean all year. But it’d been a long time since watching it, and I put on my rose-colored glasses determined to find the hints I’d missed that made it make sense.

Only to see that this is the season that committed character assassination on both brothers:
Sam—I found something I was missing
Dean—recites list of every mistake Sam ever made including ones he wasn’t responsible for, like being soulless
Sam—Well, then you’re better off without me
Dean—You just don’t realize what you want so I will make you want to be a hunter again by reciting the list of every mistake you ever made
Sam—Okay, I’ll do something really hard to fix it
Dean—recites list
Sam—You and the world are better off without me
Dean—Screw the world, I can’t live without my brother

It’s all written very ‘hit the viewers over the head because nuance is too subtle’ and it’s like the writers never watched the first 5 seasons at all.

At the end of the rewatch I realized I cared more about several of the guest stars than I did about Sam and Dean—in fact the only reason to watch this season again is to appreciate Kevin Tran and Benny and Garth and Charlie and Grandpa Winchester and Aaron, the kid with the golem, in their stand-alone episodes.

Sigh. So here are the individual episode thoughts. I apologize in advance for how snarky they are this time.
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 7

I jumped in to season 7 optimistically—season 6 was pretty good, so season 7 had to be better than I remembered it being, right?

Yeah, no. Sadly it was worse than I remembered.
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 6

General Observation—When you watch season 6 knowing the secrets behind the behavior of Sam and Cas the season really holds up. And once again we get to watch Dean suffer through feeling betrayed by his brother and best friend, angsting about the mega-monster problem, and finding out that family doesn’t mean the same thing to others…

To the episodes—

Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 5

Season 5 was the first season I watched live, and it’s been a really long time since I’ve watched it. Rewatching it, particularly knowing what comes in later seasons, I have to say it was a very emotionally gripping season. There were only 2 episodes that I felt were duds.

Season 4 was about Sam taking the wrong path because of his pride. Season 5 was watching Dean lose his hope, his belief that what he did mattered. And when it ended I felt as bereft now as I had back in 2010.

Side note about the DVDs—until this season, each disk had an option to watch with or without the recap (THEN) and you had to set it to ‘on’ or the episode just begins with NOW. As of season 5 this was discontinued, every episode begins with the recap. Also there was only 1 commentary for the whole season.
Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 4

General Observations—I remembered this season as the one where Sam and Dean’s relationship falls apart because they don’t communicate, and started this rewatch looking for the signs. Interestingly, it felt different than I remembered it.

Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
Rewatch of Supernatural 2022

Season 3 General Observations

We saw as early as the season 1 episode ‘Faith’ that Dean, despite his bravado, suffered from low self-esteem, and that played out in his decision to trade his soul for Sam’s life. Season 3 continues that theme for Dean, making the viewers hurt right along with Sam as Dean continues to devalue himself. What was fascinating to me this rewatch, though, was Sam’s character reveals, knowing what happens in season 4. This time around I could see how, even though he loved Dean intensely, Sam was still in competition with his big brother and that need to prove he was better—smarter—contributed to his falling for Ruby’s deception. Again, the first time through you don’t know Ruby’s real end game, but watching this time made me want to smack Sam upside the head and call him an idiot…sigh. Real kudos to the writers for laying the groundwork so well for the character development in the next season.

Read more... )
borgmama1of5: (Default)
I rewatched all 13 episodes of season 15 Saturday to prepare for October 8, and had some thoughts, mainly that there are some good episodes and good parts of episodes but there is so much wasted screen time and non-logical action that I’m struggling with dread over what the writers are doing to the last 7 episodes…

So sharing my thoughts after watching till 4:30 am…

So sharing my thoughts after watching till 4:30 am… )

Finished!

Sep. 15th, 2019 12:17 am
borgmama1of5: (Default)


Just finished the season finale and wow, I am nervous all over again about how they get out of that graveyard!!

But what really hit me hard again was that Dean chose not to shoot Jack even though Jack was fully accepting that he should die for his mistakes, and Dean made his choice without Sam saying anything. And then when Chuck offered to bring Mary back if Dean shoots Jack, that just got Dean in 'I won't be screwed with' mode. And then Chuck killed Jack anyway, dammit!

Watching the season in one fell swoop, I found it interesting that it was set up to make Michael the big bad for the season and then halfway through Michael's taken care of and suddenly Jack is the inadvertent big bad. I think Jack's character development over the last 2 seasons was really well done and Alex Calvert played him perfectly to make us feel for him doing wrong without meaning to. And in a way his behavior--doing the wrong thing while trying to do the right thing--is the same path that both Sam and Dean have taken trips down over the years, so that made me especially empathetic toward him.

Rewatching the scenes with Chuck, I wonder just how much free will the boys have had all along. I know that is supposed to be one of the arcs of this season...my feeling is that Chuck keeps putting hurdles in their path but how they get over or around them is something he sits back and watches. And maybe throws another bump if they are going in a way he doesn't care for, but that they have still worked around it with free will.

At least that's what I hope.

October 10 can't come soon enough!!!
borgmama1of5: (Default)
...with no responsibilities to anyone else on a weekend when you're not on call:

My SPN season 14 videos arrived this week and I watched the first 11 episodes Friday night until 6 am Saturday morning while eating pizza and ice cream and I will watch the rest of them today and tomorrow  :)  :)  :)

(Initial review: the writing in the first few episodes was wildly uneven...I still cannot stand the Nick storyline and the use of the character Maggie makes me crazy. However Sam and Dean/Jared and Jensen are awesome and episode 300 was practically perfect. The fact that they got the episode with John's return right gives me a little hope that they will get the series finale right as well...)

Profile

borgmama1of5: (Default)
borgmama1of5

January 2025

S M T W T F S
    1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Mar. 12th, 2026 08:59 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios